Best Pizza in Newark

There Is No Place Like Home

Everyday Special!!!

Everyday Special!!!
Call us to receive this deal (973) 481-6900.

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Fried chicken, mozzarella, and Buffalo sauce mixed with blue cheese.

Eggplant Pizza

White Pizza

Mozzarella and ricotta (no sauce).

Eggplant Parm Sub

Sub is on 10" Italian bread.

Stuffed Shells

Order From Our Website

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

High-Quality Ingredients

High-Quality Ingredients
Our pizza options are seemingly endless, from the simplicity of a plain pizza to the rich and flavorful anchovies or mushroom pizza. For those looking for something a little more adventurous, our Specialty Pizza section boasts unique offerings like our ultra-thin Tortilla Pizza and our health-conscious Broccoli, Tomato, Garlic Pizza - a dish that perfectly embodies our commitment to taste and well-being.

Freshly Prepared Pasta Dishes

Freshly Prepared Pasta Dishes
For those who prefer handheld delights, our diverse range of subs, including the Bruschetta Steak Sandwich and the Buffalo Chicken Sub, are sure to impress. Moreover, we didn't forget about the little ones - our Kid's Menu features favorites like chicken fingers, grilled cheese, and a kid-sized pizza sandwich.

Delectable Desserts!

Delectable Desserts!
Beyond food, we offer an array of drinks and desserts. From refreshing sodas and juices to indulgent fried Oreos and Zeppoles, there's always something to quench your thirst or satisfy your sweet tooth.

LET GENCARELLI'S PIZZERIA CATER YOUR NEXT BIG PARTY

LET GENCARELLI'S PIZZERIA CATER YOUR NEXT BIG PARTY
We offer a complete section of hot and cold food for your indulgence. Where your party is small or large, our Catering Staff can accomodate all of your needs.

Gencarelli's Photos

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

I always order from here when I get pizza for my daughters school. They are professional, and the food is very good. I will always be a customer. You won't be disappointed I have tried other items on the menu that are very good as well!

Renee W.

Renee W.

Phenomenal pizza. Quality mozzarella and thin tasty dough. Buffalo wings and REAL blue cheese were on point. Great deals and prices. Highly recommend.

Luis S.

Luis S.

People were friendly and the vibes in the store are very cool. I like the large selection of menu options and the team work they have is amazing! 😊 .. A friend recommended this place a while back and I've been impressed every time I walk I to the establishment.

Erica P.

Erica P.

All of the pizzas taste very good and the prices are great the people that work there are nice and friendly can't wait to go back again

Herbert W.

Herbert W.

I really enjoy eating here, we have become regulars. The receipe for the dough, sauce, and cheese is everything I am looking for in a pizza. The prices are very affordable which makes this a perfect place to get a quick dinner for my family. They deliver and. Very quickly.

Katerina R.

Katerina R.

Highly recommend Gencarelli's Pizzeria. The owner and staff are extremely friendly and make you feel at home. They understand quality service and a quality product. Don't miss your chance to make Gencarelli's your new favorite pizzeria!

David R.

David R.

Featuring

Catering

Healthy Options

Easy Parking

Come and Try Us!

Come and Try Us!
At Gencarelli's, our menu extends far beyond pizzas. We serve a variety of appetizers, from classic wings and cheesy garlic bread to our unique Disco Dipper Fries and Ghost Dipper Fries. Our pasta dishes, like the Baked Ziti and Spaghetti with Meatballs, are comfort food at its best, and our stuffed breads - such as the Calzone and Stromboli - are customer favorites.
Gencarelli's Pizzeria Rewards

Gencarelli's Pizzeria Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

Our location